I agree with both points here. I think that the biggest thing is, are you being true to yourself, the consumer and the craft? If you are using GNS to make something like Gin or infused vodkas or something of that nature that you can say "hey I hand crafted this" then great, use GNS. If you are using GNS immorally, as a shortcut or as a way to just flip it, put it in a "fancy bottle", and make money, I say shame on you and that is NOT distilling. I'm sorry but it's not. It may be in a literal sense but definitely not by what I, personally, think of when I think of distilling.
I'm sure most people would love to make their own GNS, but the fact is some of us strictly run pot stills and are unable to do so. We OURSELVES are the only ones that can keep the integrity of the industry strong. If you believe that what you are doing has some craft to it, then myself nor Chuck nor anyone else can tell you you are or are not a distiller. (although Chuck's going to tell you anyways...)
That being said I think it's important to have conversation like this in order to make people take a long hard look at themselves and what they are doing and how they are doing it.
You need to love what you're doing and how your doing it or else... WHY DO IT???
my two cents