We've recently ordered a 2500 liter mash cooker with removable wedgewire false bottom. In the past, with our 150 gallon cooker we've used a various mishmash/hodgepodge -- the most efficient of which is a 75' long - 1" diameter copper coil with tri-clamp fittings on each end. We transfer the mash from the cooker into an HDPE tote, drop in the coil, turn on the muni water supply, stir the mash and wait... and wait. We can usually get it from glucoAm temp to yeast pitch temp in and hour or so. Results are much worse in the summer when ground water temps hover around 68F.
For our expansion (thanks to Mike @ MG Thermal Consulting) we'll have a nice chilled water system. I'd like to hear some feedback on various methods of mash chilling. After much reading the two options I've settled on are:
1. Use the existing mash cooker jacket and adapt piping to enable chilled water flow through the jacket
2. Standalone tubular cooler (think a long liebig condenser)
For #2, we've received a quote for $3,850 for the tubular which will consist of 8 (approx) 6' sections of 3" over 2" stainless with TC fittings to facilitate disassembly and cleaning. I have a number of concerns about this, the least of which how much cooling will occur in the middle 1" of mash -- is 2" too large? should it be 3" over 1½"? Can our mash pump handle the load? Additionally, it doesn't thrill me to have another piece of equipment to trip over, move around, and clean.
As for #1, I've heard of folks doing this but have no first (or eve second) hand knowledge. I can't imagine it would cost more than $3,850 for the needed valves & piping. If my (grossly generalized) calcs are correct, I need to remove about a half-millon BTUs from the mash to get it to pitching temps ((185 - 85) * 600 gallons * 8.4 lbs / gallon).
I digress...
If any here can share your methods for large-volume mash cooling or other thoughts I'd be appreciative.